The Struggles of Boston's Black Workers in the Civil War Era
October 3, 2022
Boston’s reputation as an abolitionist hotbed in the decades before the Civil War belies the “casual cruelty” its Black residents endured, according to this eye-opening history. Bancroft Prize winner Jones (Goddess of Anarchy) notes that Black Bostonians “enjoyed rights denied to their counterparts in other parts of the North,” but claims that the city’s abolitionists, while eloquent and well-organized, had limited sway. Even fiery antislavery activist William Lloyd Garrison refrained from advocating for improved conditions for the city’s Black workforce, lest he alienate potential supporters of abolitionism. Though few white Bostonians publicly expressed support for enslavement, many residents, “Brahmin” aristocrats and Irish immigrants alike, refused to accept people of color as their equals, according to Jones. Denied entry to “conventional workplaces,” many Black Bostonians found jobs as “rat catchers, youthful errand-runners for professional gamblers, dance-hall musicians, and scammers.” Expertly drawing from court records, newspaper articles, and other primary sources, Jones interweaves fine-grained accounts of internal debates with the antislavery movement with poignant depictions of the struggles and triumphs of ordinary Black Bostonians. The result is a nuanced and noteworthy addition to the history of race relations in America.
Starred review from November 15, 2022
Superb social history of a Boston that, while nominally abolitionist, found little room in its 19th-century economy for Black workers. In the years leading to the Civil War, writes Bancroft Prize-winning historian Jones, Black Bostonians faced numerous obstacles. There was old-fashioned "overt racial prejudice," and then there was the related "hard-nosed calculation that the white laboring classes were too potent a political force to aggravate with calls for Black economic opportunity." Competition with newly arrived Irish immigrants for low-wage work often saw Blacks unable to secure adequate employment. Given that "wage earning was a key signifier of citizenship," Blacks in Boston were effectively less than full citizens. Even the onset of Civil War and, in time, the admission of Black troops into the Army did little to address basic inequalities. As so often explains matters historical, much of this had to do with economics. For example, while laws that "required Black seamen to be incarcerated while their ships were in southern ports" may have drawn murmurs of protest on the parts of sailors and abolitionists, the shipowners were disinclined to join them, recognizing that those ports represented money. In the end, Jones shows with her characteristic combination of meticulous research and able storytelling, while Blacks constituted a small segment of the professional classes, many more required public assistance, which worked, abolitionists feared, to prove that Blacks were naturally indolent and that their objection to "ill-paid, disagreeable work was somehow a function of their 'race.' " Even after the war, nothing changed: Many Boston jobs required political patronage available only to White workers, and as a result, "for the period 1865 to 1920, Black men constituted just barely 1 percent of the commonwealth's workforce." Arguably, those patterns of old endure today, if perhaps better disguised than the open racism of old. A brilliant expos� of hypocrisy in action, showing that anti-Black racism reigned on both sides of the Mason-Dixon Line.
COPYRIGHT(2022) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from January 1, 2023
Antebellum-era Boston was one of the central cities in the antislavery movement in the nineteenth century. While prominent northern white abolitionists spoke out about the injustices that African-descended, enslaved people went through in the south, they failed to address issues affecting Black communities closer to home, who faced housing and job discrimination. Jones breaks down the economic and social hostilities of the 1850s and beyond that posed challenges to Black workers in Boston. From the 1640s, when Boston became the first city in New England to legalize slavery, Jones expands on how the systems were built that exploited Black labor even after the abolishment of slavery in Massachusetts in the 1780s. Many notable figures are profiled in this comprehensive volume, ranging from William Lloyd Garrison to lesser-known Black leaders, including Sarah Parker Remond, a full-time abolitionist lecturer. Suited to academic and large public-library collections, No Right to an Honest Living is an essential text for readers seeking to uncover material that challenges the myths of the north offering better economic conditions for Black communities and details the layers of struggles they faced for generations.
COPYRIGHT(2023) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.